Blog

By: Jason Bane

Category: Media

Posted: September 15, 2005 6:00 AM

Colorado Media Bias Exists on Both Sides of the Aisle

President Bush has been facing criticism in the wake of the problems surrounding the relief efforts of Hurricane Katrina, which has ultimately caused some die-hard supporters to resort to the time-honored tradition of blaming media bias for their troubles. This is a common theme, advanced by the White House itself to deflect criticism by saying "we're not going to play the blame game." Occasionally supporters from the Left will chime back a particular point, say, that The Denver Post endorsed President Bush for re-election, as evidence that the media trends conservative. Of course, some media entities (such as the conservative Fox News) are indeed inherently biased, but most discerning and politically-savvy viewers already know that. But the truth about media bias in Colorado, I think, is with the individual. In Colorado, there are columnists and editorial writers who are clearly on one side or the other. Vincent Carroll of the Rocky Mountain News consistently leans to the right, while Mike Littwin generally leans left. There are extreme examples, of course, such as the News' Mike Rosen, who leans so far to the right that he walks in circles; the Denver Post's David Harsanyi is basically a Republican Party staffer; and the Post's Diane Carman is absurdly biased towards Democrats. Then there are those columnists who try to present a fair front but don't always make it. This column from the News' Peter Blake is basically a Republican Party newsletter, and when you look over the past couple of months, most of Blake's columns are about Republicans -- and written favorably. People like to proclaim that journalists should be unbiased, and they're right. But politicians should also be honest and cats shouldn't scratch the hell out of your furniture when you spend so much money feeding them. Things aren't always the way they should be. Journalists are humans, and humans have opinions. We're all biased. Sometimes, what looks like bias can just be an innocent decision. This story on 9News.com about Rep. Tom Tancredo was one of their top seven stories for most of the day on Thursday. Was this one of the seven biggest stories in Colorado on Thursday? Of course not. Is that because the web producers are biased or because they thought it might generate more interest? Sometimes, bias can appear by accident. Take a look at two recent headlines about President Bush on 9News.com. Each story was written by a different person: Bush picks John Roberts to be chief justice, replacing Rehnquist This isn't necessarily a biased headline, but it is very misleading. Bush didn't make Roberts the new chief justice; he just indicated his preference that Roberts get that post. Now look at another headline that may have been written innocently but seems to be clearly biased: Bush tours devastated Gulf Coast, faults recovery efforts as 'not enough' This headline is pretty flattering for President Bush -- and it's quite a bit misleading. President Bush, after all, is getting much of the blame for the slow and inefficient response to Hurricane Katrina because it happened on his watch. But in reading this headline you would think that the response problems had nothing to do with Bush or his decisions. The White House's standard line has been to deflect criticism by blaming local authorities, and the writer of this 9News.com story seems to have bought that hook, line and proverbial sinker. So the next time you want to trot out media bias as the cause of your favorite politician's troubles, remember that in many cases it's media bias that does just as good a job propping up that very politician. Like most things in life, bias works both ways.
Comments

re: Ehrhart's response - We do have a great country and for the most part we appear to be proud of it...unfortunately, being a democracy makes it not only a privilege but an obligation to hold it's leaders, along with its media reporting on those leaders, accountable for their musings, be they bias or otherwise. Others outside of this country should expect to hold us to that same standard; a standard by which we travel the globe and force upon many a country. Our dirty laundry and the right to air it should not be considered slamming of faults, but rather keeping the bar raised to the standard by which our forefathers set and died for to protect (in essence) the freedom of speech (which encompasses "bias"). As a result, we definitely have no problem seeing the grandstanding of efforts (be they good or bad) in this country. Finally, If our media attempted, at any point, to "protect" our country from shame or criticism it would contradict the most popular of our amendments in this country (the 1st).

I would just like to agree with you that we are all biased! Sure we are! And I think the the Media is not really biased toward one party or the other, but istead, they are biased toward their ratings. A story isn't going to sell unless it is dripping with scandal and corruption. At least it isn't going to air unless it finds fault or it brings tears to our eyes. When we air our dirty laundry nationally, we are only hurting ourselves. I'd like to see the media attempt to protect our country from shame and criticism that we constantly receive from our neighbors. We have a beautiful country and we are proud of who we are! We should be grandstanding our efforts and not slamming our faults!

The difference between Mike Littwin and Vincent Carroll is that Carroll isn't just a columnist, he's the editor of the Rocky editorial pages. He writes unsigned editorials, supervises people like plagiarist Thom Beal who also wrote unsigned editorials, decides which candidates and ballot measures are endorsed by the paper, and presumably plays a role in which letters to the editor are published and which syndicated op-eds will appear in the Rocky. Carroll and Littwin don't somehow balance each other -- it's not an apples-to-apples comparison. Peter Blake, like Carroll, is also a member of the Rocky editorial board, which means he has too has more influence than Littwin over the editorial stance of the Rocky. Everyone may be biased, but some papers are more biased than others.

Facebook Comments Box

Denver Real Estate 2013 - Get In The Game

Here’s why it’s finally time to get back in the Denver real estate market.

Spin Cities

We’ve highlighted some of the best road cycling routes along the Front Range and in the high...

Risky Business

Colorado’s labor market has more than its share of occupational hazards.

Escape

Each year, more than 18,000 victims of domestic violence call SafeHouse Denver’s hot line. Meet...

Get Well

From obesity to food allergies, we break down five issues facing Colorado’s kids.