Blog

By: Michael de Yoanna

Category: Panorama

Posted: March 1, 2010 12:11 PM

Tags: CODY ENGELHAUPT, PEOPLE

Boulder Scientist Stands Up for Tiny Pluto in Planet Debate

Though the International Astronomical Union recently shocked the world by concluding that Pluto is not a planet, but rather a giant boulder amid the Kuiper Belt of icy rocks, Boulder's Alan Stern, one of the country's foremost Pluto scientists, is rallying on behalf of the "dwarf planet" at the edge of the Solar System. Stern will appear in "The Pluto Files" on PBS' Nova Tuesday night, when he's expected to advocate the simple "Star Trek" test in which he postulates Captain Kirk would have described Pluto as a planet. "The Star Trek test is really easy," Stern tells the Daily Camera. "You look at the picture of the thing, and it's pretty much decided in the mind. It's a rock, it's a planet, it's an asteroid, it's a star." Neil deGrasse Tyson, who in 2000 sparked controversy when his Solar System exhibit at the Hayden Planetarium in New York relegated Pluto to the Kuiper, will take on Stern. The debate may involve new dimensions by 2015, when after nine years NASA's New Horizons spacecraft visits Pluto. Stern, with NASA, is anticipating that mission. Want to see the best guess at what Pluto would look like if you were flying by in a spaceship now? Check out a recent groundbreaking animation (via Wired).

Comments

Go Alan! The IAU shocked the world because four percent of its members created an unusable planet definition through a process that violated the group's own bylaws. Their decision makes no sense in saying that dwarf planets are not planets and in defining objects solely by where they are while ignoring what they are. If Earth were in Pluto's orbit, according to the IAU definition, it would not be a planet either. The IAU further compounded its blunder by refusing all requests from astronomers to reopen the discussion at its 2009 General Assembly. Even Neil de Grasse Tyson acknowledges the issue is not settled, and that there is no consensus among astronomers on this issue. The IAU may have intended to end the debate, but their decision is becoming more and more irrelevant.

Facebook Comments Box

Denver Real Estate 2013 - Get In The Game

Here’s why it’s finally time to get back in the Denver real estate market.

Spin Cities

We’ve highlighted some of the best road cycling routes along the Front Range and in the high...

Risky Business

Colorado’s labor market has more than its share of occupational hazards.

Escape

Each year, more than 18,000 victims of domestic violence call SafeHouse Denver’s hot line. Meet...

Get Well

From obesity to food allergies, we break down five issues facing Colorado’s kids.