SubscribeAvailable Now

Cheap Eats: Fat Sully’s NY Pizza


In early December, Colfax’s Bluebird District welcome Fat Sully’s NY Pizza to the hood. Tucked inside the Atomic Cowboy, the spot’s menu is small (just five pizza varieties, including fat-free and gluten-free versions), but it’s cheap, with pieces going for $2.50, plus 35-cent toppings.

Servings are enormous (the large pizza is a whopping 20-inch pie), and the cheesy, thin-crusted slices beg to be folded, á la New York. Dine in (and play games like Connect Four or Sorry while you wait) or call for delivery until 1 a.m.

3237 E. Colfax Ave., 303-333-4440

Editors' Picks


Keep me up to date on the latest trends and happenings around Denver. 5280 has a newsletter for everyone.

Sign Up